Episode 230 | Is Toby the Scranton Strangler? with Paul Lieberstein

January 8, 2025

Is Toby the Scranton Strangler?? This week the ladies discuss this very popular fan theory! In old school debate style, they each take a side and present their case. Angela vs Jenna. Angela says that Toby IS the Scranton Strangler and Jenna argues that he is NOT. With the help of many “Office Ladies” fans writing in with their theories and the ladies' own deep-divey research, this debate gets heated! Sam becomes the impromptu judge and Cassi serves as the debate expert but ultimately we needed to hear from Paul Lieberstein aka Toby Flenderson himself. He joins the ladies in the studio to answer this fan theory once and for all! Is Toby the Scranton Strangler? We want to hear your thoughts! We hope you enjoy this episode, we never knew we could have so much fun talking about Toby.